Several cast members representing lots of prior BETM experience led the BETM production at the Patchogue Theatre, July 22 to August 8, 2015.
The cast was led by veteran Billy Mitchell Tobin, who originally debuted as Billy as part of the North American Tour production in December of 2012. Mitchell went on to star as Billy in London, then reprised the role in the US regional productions at the La Mirada and Alex Theatres in California, before starring again as Billy most recently at Music Theatre Wichita in Kansas.
Janet Dickinson first played Mrs. Wilkinson in the North American Tour cast of the show and later reprised the role in the US regional productions at the North Carolina Theatre and Music Theatre Wichita.
Patti Perkins was the standby for Grandma in the Broadway production, originated the role for the North American Tour production and played the role in the regional productions of the show at The MUNY (St. Louis) and Music Theatre Wichita.
Kilty Reidy was in the final cast as Mr. Braithwaite for the North American Tour of BETM when it ended its run in Sao Paulo, Brazil in 2013 and reprised the role in the Music Theatre Wichita production.